subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Nov 24 2009 

Published: October 24, 2009 03:54 pm    print this story   email this story  

TRIBUNE-STAR EDITORIAL: Experiment gone wrong

Daniels does right thing by ending contract with IBM for privatization of state’s welfare system

Mistakes can hurt people. Those wounds get compounded when the mistake continues and goes unacknowledged.

Gov. Mitch Daniels did the right thing by ending an experiment gone wrong — the privatization of the state of Indiana’s delivery of welfare services. Daniels canceled the $1.34 billion contract with IBM, the company hired in 2006 to process food stamps, Medicaid and welfare cases. The deal with IBM substantially changed the way 1.2 million Hoosiers pursue those essential services. The previous state-run system of recipients meeting with case workers gave way to automation. The new system proved to be a sad failure.

People needing medical or food assistance were asked to contact the FSSA online or by phone at new state call centers. But the applicants’ calls frequently were lost or went unanswered — a costly setback for a poor person with limited cell phone minutes. Their paperwork often disappeared. Foul-ups took weeks or months to correct. Indiana legislators heard a litany of complaints and heart-wrenching stories about life-saving prescriptions going unfilled.

Indiana’s old welfare system needed fixing. Errors, fraud and slow service plagued that structure, too. But the modernization attempt under the IBM pact was the wrong remedy.

Thankfully, the governor acknowledged his administration’s misstep, albeit a little late. “It was a flawed concept that simply did not work in practice,” Daniels said. He even conceded his critics were right, saying, “Those who raised concerns about service quality were correct, and we appreciate their efforts. We’ll now take the best parts of the old and new, and move ahead with a hybrid system in what amounts to a major mid-course correction.”

That righting of the welfare ship is receiving intense scrutiny, and rightly so. The IBM system ends Dec. 14, and the hybrid plan takes over. Face-to-face contacts with case workers in each Indiana county will return. However, the state will retain the computerized, paperless record-keeping system operated by IBM subcontractor Affiliated Computer Services. Many Indiana lawmakers are uneasy with the continued involvement with ACS. The state’s negotiations with that Dallas-based firm and IBM were overseen by former FSSA secretary Mitch Roob, an ACS executive alum.

On Friday, Roob’s replacement — Anne Murphy — met with the legislature’s State Budget Committee to discuss the transition to the hybrid system. The lawmakers’ questions and concerns should begin a period of transparent review of the way Indiana connects needy residents to food and medical help. By Dec. 14, the real-life impact of this new system must be fully understood by the state and the people relying on its assistance.

print this story   email this story  



Terre Haute Progress Retail health medical manufacturing education

Terre Haute
autoconx
Visit zip2save.com for all your favorite circulars & coupons!
Circulars
Coupons
Deals Zip2Save.com, online advertising circulars, deals, coupons and travel specials.
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Terre Haute

Terre Haute News Morning Headlines

Terre Haute ClickLocal

Terre Haute Tribune-Star Newspaper Dial-A-Pro

Terre Haute Tribune-Star Newspaper Live in the Clubs

Terre Haute News on Twitter

Premium Jobs

MANAGEMENT (KEYHOLDER) POSITION WITH LOCAL
shoe store. Exciting career opportunity. Retail experience preferred. Competitive benefit package. Apply at SHOE SHOW, 2...>MORE

NOW HIRING OWNER OPERATORS
Call 270-678-7379....>MORE

ELECTRICIAN WANTED. KY LICENSE PREFERRED.
OSHA 10 hr. 10+ years exp., commercial, EOE, Drug free workplace. Job is located in Glasgow, KY. Interested applicants c...>MORE

EXPERIENCED DENTAL ASSISTANT NEEDED
to work 2-3 days a week in a busy dental office, emphasizing in oral surgery. Pay commensurate on experience & backgroun...>MORE

CAREER MINDED INDIVIDUALS SEARCHING FOR A HOME
We offer HOME ON WEEKENDS!!
2500 miles per week
100% no touch freight
No force dispatch to NYC. Safety & ...>MORE

DENTAL HYGIENIST POSITION,
part time and or as needed. Send resume to P.O. Box 1172, Tompkinsville, KY 42167.

...>MORE

ADULT THERAPIST
LifeSkills has a full-time Adult Therapist position available for our service center in Metcalfe County. The position is...>MORE

See all ads
Premium Autos

93 CHEVROLET CONVERSION VAN,
123,000+ miles., new tires, runs & looks great. Must see. $1795 O.B.O. 453-3726 or 670-8131.

...>MORE

2000 NISSAN QUEST SE, 114K.
98 Chevy Lumina, 77K, excellent tires on both. $3,200 each. Call 270-590-2789.

...>MORE

2002 HONDA TRIKE GL-1800
40k miles. Asking $27,000. For more info call 270-404-2959.

...>MORE

LOOKING FOR A GREAT AUTO DEAL?.....
Looking to buy or sell?
Check here for the Premium Auto Section.
You can post an ad with unlimited text and ...>MORE

See all ads
Premium Homes

2 BR, 1 BA DUPLEX, $650 MO. ALL UTILITIES PAID,
C/H/A, WD hookup, stove, DW, ref., storage unit furnished.
rear deck. Harwood St. $425 mo. 678-5982. or 670-5745....>MORE

4 BR, 1 BATH HOUSE,
Refrigerator and stove furnished. $425 mo. plus $200 deposit. 270-576-4209.

...>MORE

2 BR MOBILE HOME, $360 MO. + DEP.
& utilities. In small mobile home park. 270-202-9148 or 529-9148. Leave message....>MORE

2 BR, 1 BA, C/H/A, W/D HOOKUP, STOVE, D/W,
refrigerator, storage unit furnished, rear deck. $400 mo. + $300 dep. 678-5982 or 670-5745.

...>MORE

PRICE REDUCED $25,000. STEEPLECHASE SUBD.,
2500 sq. ft., 3 BR, office, 2 1/2 BA, fireplace, 2 car attached garage. $224,500. 270-670-8903.

...>MORE

3 BR, 2 BA, MOBILE HOME, CENTRAL H/A,
all electric, 14'x70', $350 mo. + $75 dep. to move in. Sewer & garbage furnished. Call for details. 590-0775 or 590-0779...>MORE

EXECUTIVE HOME IN NORRIS COURT,
4 BR, 2 1/2 BA, 3300 sq. ft., full unfinished basement, 2 car detached garage, completely remodeled. $199,000. Call 615-...>MORE

1 BR APARTMENT $425 MO.
utilities paid, inside city limits, service animals only. 270-590-8914.

...>MORE

RENT TOO HIGH? CALL US FOR SPECIALS.
Best Deal In Glasgow. November Free! Only $350 mo. Newly remodeled 2 BR, 1 BA apartments, all appliances furnished. WD h...>MORE

GLASGOW CITY, LARGE 2 BR APARTMENT, C/H/A,
close to hospital, fridge & range furnished, W/D hook-up. Dep. & references required. $375 mo. Call 270-773-5189 or 270-...>MORE

See all ads
Today's Featured Jobs

Advertising Sales
ADVERTISING
SALES
$800-$1200 Weekly
Be your own boss.
Sell advertising to
businesses in your ...>MORE

Food Service
Do you have
FOOD SERVICE
experience? If the
answer is yes, Call
812-232-0373
...>MORE

See all ads
Today's Featured Autos

87 Chrysler
1987 Chrysler
LeBaron GTS,
Runs Good, de-
pendable $700 Firm
(217)275-3217
...>MORE

98 S10
98 S10 4cyl, auto,
custom paint $2000,
(812)235-7718...>MORE

See all ads
Today's Featured Homes

Woodgate East
Lg 3 bdr, 2 ba, gar-
den apts, w/pool,
in beautiful Wood-
gate East. W/D
hookup, all new ap-
...>MORE

1 or 2 bdrm
1 or 2 bdrm
(812)238-9913,
(812)232-7932...>MORE

See all ads
Today's Cool Stuff

Treadmill
Treadmill for
Sale, ProForm, Like
New, $400 available
Nov 21 841-9272

...>MORE

Wanted: Guns
wanted: Guns
Browning Colts, etc.
Bob (812)446-7067
...>MORE

See all ads

Loading Calendar...
(requires Javascript)
© 1995-2009, The Tribune Star, TribStar.com 222 South 7th Street, Terre Haute, Indiana 47807 • Phone: (812) 231-4200
Advertising • Circulation • Editorial • Administrative • Online
Place a Classified Ad
rtj

 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc. • CNHI Classified Advertising Network • CNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index