subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Feb 09 2010 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published October 25, 2008 11:01 am - Coal is a complicated subject. And the people who live in Kentucky’s coal-producing regions have a “complicated history with coal,” as author and musician Silas House puts it.

Mongiardo misrepresents reporter’s reaction to mountaintop removal


By RONNIE ELLIS
CNHI News Service

FRANKFORT

Coal is a complicated subject. And the people who live in Kentucky’s coal-producing regions have a “complicated history with coal,” as author and musician Silas House puts it.

I learned that again a few days ago. Kentucky’s Lt. Gov. Daniel Mongiardo, a physician and surgeon from Hazard, has a complicated history with coal. He’s an outspoken proponent of coal and what mining it can do for the region he clearly loves.

Mongiardo invited me to Hazard to see “the good side of mountaintop removal.” My first thought was, isn’t the “good side” the one they blast away in order to remove the mountaintop? Mongiardo concedes the ugliness of an active surface mine site but, making an analogy you’d expect from a surgeon, says properly reclaimed land is a small scar on a healthier patient.

He showed me majestic elk on a reclaimed site, an ATV training center, and an impressive sports complex. I met some really good people. He extolled the virtues of adventure tourism on flattened mountains. He introduced me to an impressive man, David Duff, who operates a mining site – by mining standards – in an exemplary fashion. We looked at 12-inch seams of coal in a high wall so I’d understand it can’t be efficiently mined any other way. At the bottom of what’s left of the mountain, Duff drank from a stream fed by runoff from the mining site. But I noticed Dr. Mongiardo didn’t – and he later said he wouldn’t.

At one reclaimed site Mongiardo said: “If you didn’t know better, you’d think you were in central Kentucky.” No. More importantly, I asked, if one wants to live in central Kentucky, why wouldn’t one move there instead of trying to turn a awesomely beautiful place into something other than what God created and which shapes the magnificent spirit and character of the equally wonderful people who live there?

At the end of the day, I thanked Mongiardo. I told him I recognized his genuine passion for eastern Kentucky and his understandable desire to pump economic life into the region. But, I concluded, neither the elk, the trails nor the faulty rationale could eradicate the scarred images from my mind nor the sense that we are in the process of destroying something which is sacred to the people of southeastern Kentucky in order to preserve it. You simply can’t preserve something by destroying it, I told him. For what does it profit eastern Kentucky if it sells its soul?

That’s why I was so surprised to learn Mongiardo told a meeting of the Kentucky Coal Association in Lexington a week later that he’d taken a reporter to show him the reality of mining and, “I think he’s got a different attitude now because he saw it first-hand.” He didn’t name me, but there were people in the room who knew Mongiardo spoke of me.

Coal is going to be with us for a long time. As I’ve heard others who live in the region say, I’m not against mining, I’m opposed to this kind of mining. But in the end, it’s not for me to tell the people of southeastern Kentucky what to do. I don’t live there – though when I visit I sure wish I did. It’s their land, and more importantly it’s their way of life. It’s a complicated history they have with coal. They must decide.

But keep the coal operators and the politicians out of the discussion. Let the people who live there and whose way of life is at stake decide. Because Mongiardo demonstrated once again before the coal association the sole determination of coal interests and politicians is to mine coal, no matter what the cost – and no matter what the facts.

Ronnie Ellis writes for CNHI News Service and is based in Frankfort. He can be reached by e-mail at rellis@cnhi.com.



print this story    email this story   






autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

TEMP TO PERM INDUSTRIAL OPENINGS
in Glasgow area. Drug screen required. Must be able to work all shifts. Good pay with health insurance available. Apply ...>MORE

COURIER JOURNAL HAS MOTOR ROUTE CARRIR POSITION AVAILABLE.
So. Barren/Allen Co. Scottsville area. 7 days per week, early morning hours approximate gross monthly profit $1,500. Rou...>MORE

SISTER SCHUBERT'S HOMEMADE ROLLS IS A NATIONALLY
recognized food manufacturing company. We are seeking candidates for the following positions at our production facility ...>MORE

LOCAL COMPANY LOOKING TO HIRE CDL DRIVER.
Class B, HAZ-MAT, endorsement. Good pay and benefits. Fax resume to 678-9407.

...>MORE

GILLIE HYDE FORD IS LOOKING FOR FULL TIME POSITION
for the parts department. Prior parts experience is highly preferred but not necessary. Please see www.gilliehyde.com ...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Autos

2001 FORD ESCORT, 160 ZX2, 2 DR., AUTO, AIR,
leather, moonroof, 120k, red & ready. $3,500 OBO. 670-7557....>MORE

95 CHEVY LUMINA, 78K, NEW TIRES, 1 OWNER
$2,995. 01 Mercury Merquis LS, loaded, 77k, nice. $5,900. (270) 590-2789....>MORE

CRUISE BIKE, 2006 HONDA VTX,
1300cc, 14,442 miles, silver, garage kept, excellent condition. $8,000.00 OBO. 270-579-6956. Will send photo upon reques...>MORE

LOOKING FOR A GREAT AUTO DEAL?.....
Looking to buy or sell?
Check here for the Premium Auto Section.
You can post an ad with unlimited text and
...>MORE

2009 NISSAN ROGUE S, 16,000 MILES. STILL UNDER
Factory warranty. Must sell. 270-590-1440....>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

2 BR, 2 BA MOBILE HOME IN THE COUNTRY.
$375 mo. $100 dep. references required. Service animals only. Call 270-678-3039.

...>MORE

2 BR, 1 BA C/H/A W/D hook-up dec
mowing provided. 100B Bale Terrace www.post-web.net $400 mo. + dep. 270-361-2767 or 707-887-7429....>MORE

NEWLY PAINTED 2 BR HOUSE W/UPSTAIRS, FULL BSMT.,
appliances, furnished. 424 McKenna St. $500 mo. 270-784-4496 or 270-563-4998....>MORE

FOR SALE BY OWNER,
Possible owner financing/land contract. 816 Lexington. 3 BR, 2 BA home on 3/4 acre lot. Remodeled w/new custom maple cab...>MORE

HOUSE W/LAND OPTION.
3 or 4 BR w/3 BA, 1700 sq. ft. on main level + complete finished basement. Great kitchen, w/open floor plan & stainless ...>MORE

2 BR, 1 BA, 101 GOODMAN ST.,
Fridge, stove, C/A included, References required. $450 mo. plus $300 deposit. 651-2100 days 651-2519 evenings....>MORE

348 JARED TYLER RD.
4 BR, 3 BA, 2650 sq. ft., open plan, approx. 10 yrs. old, finished basement. Call 270-404-3915.

...>MORE

2 BR, 2 BA DUPLEX, GARAGE, OAK CABINETS,
$550 month, $400 deposit. Energy efficient, very nice. 579-1955 or 404-1953.

...>MORE

2 BR, 1 BA, C/H/A W/D HOOK-UP, DECK, MOWING PROVIDED
100B Terrace. www.post-web.net. $400 Mo. + dep. 270-361-2767 or 707-887-7429....>MORE

SMALL 2 BR DUPLEX, LR, KITCHEN, BATH, AVAILABLE
1/10. Dep, & ref. required. Call 651-7101....>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index