subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sun, Jul 05 2009 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published December 02, 2008 10:44 am - Horse Cave’s mayor has answered a defamation of character lawsuit filed against him both in his official capacity as mayor and individually by his predecessor.

Martin answers lawsuit


By GINA KINSLOW
Glasgow Daily Times

HORSE CAVE

Horse Cave’s mayor has answered a defamation of character lawsuit filed against him both in his official capacity as mayor and individually by his predecessor.

Odell Martin, who has been mayor since January 2007, admits to a portion of the allegations made in the lawsuit by former Horse Cave Mayor JoAnne Smith, who was mayor from January 1999 to December 2006, but denies other allegations made by Smith.

In her lawsuit, Smith said since Martin took office “he has made statements during city council meetings implying the former mayor and her administration had mismanaged funds during her term in office.”

Smith also alleges that Martin has refused to sign documents and letters that would officially close a Community Development Block Grant received by the city in 2003, implying she and her administration had improperly managed the grant.

She also pointed out that Martin has refused to sign off on the 2006-07 city audit based on his belief there were financial problems with the grant, as well as other grants received by the city during the former administration.

In his answer, Martin said “any statements made during city council meetings regarding the Community Development Block Grant received by the city of Horse Cave in 2003 or the 2006-07 audit prepared by David Gilbert, CPA, will be reflected in the minutes of the meetings in question.”

In her lawsuit, Smith made reference to a July 31 special city council meeting, during which council members discussed the cutting down of several trees in the Main Street Cemetery. Smith alleges that Martin accused her of being responsible for $30,000 worth of equipment that was missing. She also alleges the conversation was repeated in a newsletter mailed to her home address and addressed to “occupant.”

Smith says the alleged exchange with Martin during the July 31 meeting injured her “honesty, integrity, morality and reputation” and exposed her to “public contempt, ridicule and injury.” She also says Martin “contributed to the maliciousness of the slander when, at his direction, a newsletter was produced and circulated throughout the city of Horse Cave.”

Martin admits he spoke at a public meeting on July 31 and has submitted the minutes of that meeting, which he says, “will speak for themselves.”

As for the newsletter, which Smith claims made reference to the verbal exchange between Smith and Martin during the July 31 meeting, Martin admitted the city of Horse Cave does distribute a newsletter “to keep the public informed about meetings that have occurred and other public events.”

Smith is asking for punitive damages because she believes Martin’s conduct to be with actual malice. She is also asking for compensation for past and future mental and emotional distress, suffering, embarrassment, mortification, humiliation and harm to her reputation, as well as payment for attorney fees. She is asking for a trial by jury.

In his answer, Martin said “if the plaintiff was damaged as alleged in her complaint, then same was caused or brought about by the act or acts of one or ones other than the defendant and for whom the defendant has no legal liability and/or responsibility.”

He also stated in his answer that Smith has failed to state a cause of action against him upon which relief can be granted and that Smith’s complaint is barred by the doctrine of official immunity and municipal immunity.



print this story    email this story   




Zillow
monster
autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

EXPERIENCED LPN OR RN TO WORK IN DR. GERMAN'S
office all day on Tuesday & Friday mornings beginning in 2 weeks. Send resume to 211 Professional Park Dr., references r...>MORE

$$$ AVON $$$
Reps need in your area! $10.00 no inventory no sales quota. Couple/Retirees/Online. Call Debbie at 270-646-4939....>MORE

FOX'S PIZZA DEN NOW HIRING ALL POSITIONS
July 6th & 7th 10 am- 5pm
•Flexible scheduling
• Uniform provided
• Discounted meals
936 Happy Valle
...>MORE

Attn: Drivers. NOW HIRING!!! National Distributors Leasing
Regional & OTR Drop & Hook Operation. Great Equipment. Don't Delay. Call recruiting today! 877-334-9677. www.driver4ndl....>MORE

ACCEPTING LPN RESUMES FOR POTENTIAL OPENING.
Mail to Women & Children's Clinic. 1411 N. Race St., Glasgow, KY 42141. No phone calls please....>MORE

ASSISTANT MANAGERS - TAKE THE REGINS ON A MILLION
dollar operation as part of our management team. You'll get the support and training you need to succeed, plus the rewar...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Autos

202 FORD F150 - 18K PRICED RIGHT.
CALL 270-678-5546....>MORE

2005 MERCURY GRAND MARQUIS
Below avg. mileage, loaded, $14,500 Call 629-2005 or 670-3694....>MORE

2005 BUICK CENTURY
168,000 miles, Good condition, $4,000.00. Call 270-678-7362....>MORE

LOOKING FOR A GREAT AUTO DEAL?.....
Looking to buy or sell?
Check here for the Premium Auto Section.
You can post an ad with unlimited text and
...>MORE

1998 OLDS 88, LOCAL ONE OWNER,
28,000 miles, V6, 3.8 liter motor, excellent condition. 270-646-7646.

...>MORE

95 NISSAN PICKUP 4 CYL., 5 SPD., 140K MI.
Serviced every 3k mi., bed topper, sharp truck. $3,400. 427-5686....>MORE

97 BONNEVILLE, ALL POWER, NEW TIRES,
radio, cassette player, A1 condition, asking $1500. 651-8525 or 404-6144.

...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

LARGE 2 BR, 1 BA DUPLEX.
Laminate floors. Energy efficient C/H/A, stove, fridge. $460 mo. 270-651-3823....>MORE

1 BR DUPLEX CEDAR ST.
Newly remodeled, rent $280 mo. Dep. required. Call 590-5379....>MORE

1-3 BEDROOM HOUSES & APARTMENTS.
270-579-3497....>MORE

NEW 3 BR, DOUBLEWIDE OR SINGLEWIDE.
Shot time only. PIck your payment program. Call today 270-678-2460....>MORE

LARGE 4 BEDROOM HOME
in Steeplechase. $1500 month. Call Beth Hinkley 270-670-8866....>MORE

3 BR HOUSE IN PARK CITY
appliance include W/D, Ref. required. $425 mo + $425 Dep. 563-4029 after 6 pm....>MORE

2 BR HOUSE AT 319 JEFFERSON ST.
Hardwood floors, $475 mo. Cell Phone 670-3139....>MORE

HOUSE IN GLASGOW 2-3 BR, 1 BA
Covered back porch, storage, Ref. & Dep. 270-432-2162....>MORE

IN EXCELLENT NEIGHBORHOOD, 3 BR, 2 FULL BA,
spacious living room, with gas fireplace. Open floor plan all on one level, 1,500 sq. ft., 2 car garage, front & back po...>MORE

214 LEE ST., DOUBLEWIDE FOR LEASE.
1998 1100 sq. ft. 3 BR, 2 Full BA, $550 mo. Leo Frank Owner/Agent. 270-792-3856....>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index